In twelve pages this paper discusses the 2000 separation of conjoined twins Jodie and Mary despite parental disapproval in an ethical, philosophical, and legal consideration that includes 1989's The Children's Act and 1998's The Human Rights Act. Six sources are cited in the bibliography.
Name of Research Paper File: RT13_SA207Law.rtf
Unformatted Sample Text from the Research Paper:
courts allowed the girls known by pseudonyms Jodie and Mary to be separated (Kaveny, 2001). Mary died. Of course, that was fully expected and becomes obvious when examining the
facts of the case. It appears at first glance unethical, but the dilemma was one that even Solomon would have difficulty with. Still, in exploring this legal and moral dilemma,
many questions crop up. The case is above all a legal problem. Although the law is sometimes not conducive to moral outcomes, in some cases it is all anyone has
to protect their rights as individuals. In this case, the dilemma is that the individuals were actually not technically individuals. The details of the case explains the dilemma.
Yet, despite the incredible emotional and moral challenges the case presents, there is the law always looking down on these children and the parents who contested the decision from the
start. Finally, there are specific laws such as the paramountcy principle of the Childrens Act of 1989 and the Human Rights Act of 1998. How do these play a role
in rendering the judges decision just? Was the decision just under the law? Many questions loom large over this disturbing case. II. Facts of the Case
The case in question was presented to Lord Justice Ward, Lord Justice Brooke and Lord Justice Robert Walker which concerns a set of conjoined twins and morality
as it enters a decision as to what to do. The case involves siamese twins Jodie and Mary who each have their own brain, heart, lungs and arms and legs
("In the supreme," 2000). The twins, who were born on August 8, 2000, were joined at the lower abdomen, and while they could be successfully separated, such an operation would